
Karnataka High Court quashed an ED money laundering probe, saying the agency cannot start PMLA cases by its own complaint.
The Karnataka High Court has quashed an Enforcement Directorate money laundering investigation naming Congress leader KY Nanje Gowda, ruling that the agency is not a "super cop" entitled to investigate anything that comes to its notice, Bar & Bench reported. The case is YB Ashwathanarayan v. Union of India.
Justice MI Arun held that the ED's power under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act is derivative, not original: it cannot open an investigation on a standalone suspicion of money laundering, and PMLA proceedings cannot continue once the predicate offence ends in the accused's favour. Under Section 66(2), material suggesting a scheduled offence must be forwarded to the agency concerned, the court said, and the Act gives the ED no express power to lodge a private complaint and then investigate on its strength.
The ED had taken up a land scam case alleging that Gowda, as chairman of the Malur Land Grant Committee, and others illegally granted 80 acres to 38 people. The agency allegedly found material on a recruitment scam at the Kolar and Chikkaballapur Milk Union, of which Gowda had been appointed chairman, and summoned YB Ashwathanarayan. After the trial court dismissed the land case for lack of the sanction needed to prosecute a public servant, the ED kept Ashwathanarayan's seized properties and filed a fresh complaint before a special court for MPs and MLAs seeking a Lokayukta probe.
The court said that allowing such a complaint, where other authorities had declined to act, would let the ED proceed against anyone it chose, contrary to the Act's requirement of an existing predicate offence. Senior Advocate Kiran S Javali appeared for the petitioners; Additional Solicitor General SV Raju appeared for the ED.
Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief




