
The High Court found the state's reply cited a Supreme Court judgment that does not exist.
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has cautioned the state against filing AI-drafted pleadings without checking them. Justice Vivek Kumar Singh found that the state's reply relied on a Supreme Court judgment that does not exist. The citation it gave belongs to a different case, on suspending a sentence in a criminal appeal.
The reply was filed in a petition by police officer Piyush Mani Tiwari, who was dismissed in 2024 without a show-cause notice, charge-sheet or inquiry. The state produced no written record of why it skipped an inquiry. The court set aside the dismissal and ordered his reinstatement. The state may still hold a regular departmental inquiry.
The judge said fictitious case law wastes court time and borders on misleading the court. He sent the judgment to the State Law Secretary and the Advocate General. The Advocate General's office is expected to make sure counsel verify citations before they are sworn on affidavit.
Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief


