
The court's Nagpur bench ended a criminal case against a man who protested over a road where a passenger died.
The Bombay High Court has ended a criminal case against a 26-year-old protester in Chandrapur district. LiveLaw and Bar & Bench report the ruling. A vehicle had overturned on the road, and one passenger died. The protesters demanded that the Public Works Department officers who built it be removed.
Justice Mahendra Chandwani of the Nagpur bench made the order on October 29. The protesters had tied a rope across the road. Yet the charge sheet named nobody whose way was blocked. Police took no statement from any passer-by. So the obstruction charge under Section 126 of the BNS failed. Without an illegal object under Section 189, the gathering was not an unlawful assembly either.
The judge cited Article 19(1)(b), the right to gather peacefully and unarmed. Vague charges cannot be used to override it, he held. Protests without violence or property damage should not draw prosecution. If that approach took hold, he said, it would be "a sad day for democracy".
Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief



