Editorial · Brief · Canada · Published 20 November 2026

Canada's top court rejects two sexual assault appeals

Canada
CanadaIllustration generated for this story · how pictures are made

The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed two sexual assault appeals that turned on the accused's state of mind.

Canadian Lawyer reports that the Supreme Court of Canada rejected appeals in two sexual assault cases on Friday. Both cases asked what the Crown must prove about the accused's state of mind. The court kept the conviction of an Ontario man. It also left in place an order for a new jury trial for an Alberta man who had been acquitted. In R. v. Degale, a trial judge acquitted Bevin Kerry Degale of aggravated sexual assault. The judge said there was no evidence that the complainant told him she did not consent. The Ontario Court of Appeal overturned the acquittal and convicted him. The Supreme Court upheld that conviction by 5-4. Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justice Mary Moreau wrote for the majority. They said the judge overlooked circumstantial evidence about Degale's state of mind. They added that Canadian law has long held that non-consent need not be communicated. Justice Sheilah Martin agreed with the result but read section 273.2(b) of the Criminal Code differently. The majority did not accept her reading.

Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief

Related stories