Editorial · Brief · United States · Published 13 November 2026

Anthropic must defend its Claude Max usage promises

United States
United StatesIllustration generated for this story · how pictures are made

A California magistrate judge let parts of a class action proceed over Anthropic's Claude Max usage claims.

A federal magistrate judge in California has allowed key parts of a proposed class action against Anthropic to go forward over how it marketed its Claude Max subscriptions, Courthouse News Service reports. US Magistrate Judge Alex Tse wrote that "the advertising in question is plausibly misleading", while dismissing several other claims. Anthropic sells Max 5x for US$100 a month and Max 20x for US$200, and its website promises Max subscribers "5x more usage than Pro" or "20x more usage than Pro". The plaintiffs, Karl Kahn and Solomon Smith, say the plans deliver far less over a full week: by their calculation, for one Claude model, Max 20x users receive six times Pro's weekly usage and Max 5x users 3.5 times. Tse said Max subscribers get five or 20 times more use in each five-hour session, but their weekly limits are not five or 20 times Pro's. Anthropic argued that customers should read "more usage" as per session, citing a help page. Tse noted that page was two hyperlinks away from the primary sales pages on claude.com and that, because customers pay monthly, they could reasonably read the promise as a monthly one. Under California's Consumers Legal Remedies Act, Tse found that Claude Code could qualify as a service. Smith's claim survived, as Tse agreed his educational use was not commercial; Kahn's was dismissed with a chance to explain what his programming tasks involve. Claims under California's unfair business practices and false advertising laws were dismissed; because the plaintiffs remain subscribers, Tse found they had not shown they could seek an order requiring Anthropic to change its marketing. Claims for negligent misrepresentation and breach of the subscription agreements continue. Tse also dismissed a claim that Anthropic broke its duty to treat customers fairly by changing usage limits during billing periods, writing that the company "didn't tighten usage limits as a bait-and-switch".

Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief

Related stories