Editorial · Brief · United States · Published 20 November 2026

Third Circuit panel sees Amy Wax's Penn suit as free speech

United States
United StatesIllustration generated for this story · how pictures are made

An appeals panel heard Amy Wax's bid to revive her suit against Penn and leaned toward a free speech view.

A three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit heard Amy Wax's appeal on Tuesday, November 17, ABA Journal reported. Wax is a professor at the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School. A Pennsylvania federal court dismissed her suit against the university in summer 2025. The panel suggested her claim that she was punished for speaking on race is better seen as a First Amendment matter than as employment discrimination. In her brief, Wax says Title VI and Section 1981 of the Civil Rights Act bar race discrimination. She also says Penn let others join demonstrations against Israel without consequence while it punished her. Law.com reported that John C. Eastman argued for Wax. Penn's lawyer questioned whether she had preserved her appeal arguments and had plausibly alleged discrimination or retaliation. The suit challenges Penn's sanctions, including suspension on half pay, loss of summer pay and removal of her named chair.

Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief

Related stories