
India's Supreme Court held that an umpire cannot award more than the sum a party referred to arbitration.
India's Supreme Court has ruled that an umpire cannot award more than the sum a party stated when it referred its dispute to arbitration, LiveLaw reports. Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma decided the case under the Arbitration Act, 1940.
GMB Ceramics began arbitration against Neycer (India) Ltd in 1989, over a 1986 technical collaboration agreement for a sanitaryware plant. In correspondence naming its arbitrator, GMB put its claim at US$238,000 (₹2 crore). The umpire later awarded about US$1.4 million (₹11.69 crore). In 2015 a single judge of the Calcutta High Court cut the award to US$238,000 (₹2 crore). A division bench reversed that in 2018, and Neycer appealed.
The Supreme Court restored the single judge's order. It held that later letters and a reservation of rights could not widen the reference. It also upheld the rejection of a claim for projected advertising costs, because the higher estimate was not proved. Neycer had deposited US$476,000 (₹4 crore), covering principal and interest, and GMB had withdrawn it. The court treated that sum as full and final payment.
Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief


