
The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed Bevin Kerry Degale's appeal by 5-4, confirming his aggravated sexual assault conviction.
Canadian Lawyer reports that the Supreme Court of Canada ruled on two sexual assault appeals on November 20 and dismissed both. In R. v. Degale, it kept an Ontario man's conviction by a 5-4 vote. In the other case, it left standing an order for a new jury trial for an Alberta man.
The trial judge had acquitted Bevin Kerry Degale because the Crown had not proved criminal intent. The Ontario Court of Appeal set that aside and convicted him of aggravated sexual assault. Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justice Mary Moreau, for the majority, held that the trial judge was wrong to demand evidence that the complainant told him she did not consent.
Justice Sheilah Martin agreed with the result. She read section 273.2(b) of the Criminal Code as a second way for the Crown to prove fault: the accused did not take reasonable steps to check consent. The majority did not accept that reading.
Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief




