
Karnataka High Court rules a magistrate need not always hear another witness before taking cognisance of defamation.
The Karnataka High Court on Thursday refused to quash a criminal defamation case brought by Congress MLA Shivananda S Patil against expelled BJP MLA Basanagouda Ramangouda Patil Yatnal, Bar & Bench reports.
Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde rejected Yatnal's argument that the trial court should have examined a witness, other than the complainant, who could say Patil's reputation had fallen in that witness's estimation before it took cognisance. The court held that the phrase "in the estimation of others" in Explanation 4 to Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code, or Section 356(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, does not make such an examination compulsory in every case; whether it is needed depends on the imputation and the facts.
The complaint, filed on 18 July 2025, concerns remarks Yatnal allegedly made in an interview broadcast on 30 April 2025 on the YouTube channel of Gadinada Kranti. A magistrate took cognisance on 24 January 2026 and summoned Yatnal, relying on the complaint, a pen-drive transcript, video clips and the sworn statements of Patil and two witnesses.
The High Court found the remarks prima facie capable of lowering Patil's reputation and said the sufficiency of evidence is a question for trial. Advocate Dalwai Venkatesh appeared for Yatnal and Senior Advocate Ravi B Naik for Patil.
Published under the editorial responsibility of Kelly Moon, Editor-in-Chief



